A CASE REPORT ON THE ROLE OF HOMOEOPATHY IN THE TREATMENT OF TINEA CORPORIS
Harshita Kulshrestha(1), Sindhu Suryawanshi(2), Ankit Srivastava(3)
(1)PG Scholar, Department of Homoeopathic Materia Medica, Government Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh- 462003.
(2)Professor and HOD, Department of Homoeopathic Materia Medica, Government Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh- 462003.
(3)Medical Officer (AYUSH Department), Government of Madhya Pradesh, India.
ABSTRACT
Introduction-
Tinea corporis, also known as “ringworm” is a superficial dermatophyte infection of the skin. Tinea corporis is mostly caused by dermatophytes belonging to one of the three genera, namely, Trichophyton, Microsporum, Epidermophyton. The standard treatment of tinea corporis is with topical antifungals medications.
Aim and objective-To study the role of individualized constitutional Homoeopathic medicine in case of Tinea corporis.
Case Presentation-This article details a case of 26 year-old male who presented with Eruptions on Arms, axilla and chest since 1 month. There was severe pruritis along with Smarting and burning sensation after scratching. On Examination of the skin eruptions, it was found that they had Erythematous edges with central clearing (Tinea Corporis).
Basis of prescription-The final selection for prescription was the Homoeopathic medicine Sepia Officinalis, which is prepared from liquid obtained from the Ink Bag of the Cuttlefish, which was prescribed in 200 CM Potency after reviewing the Materia medica.
Result-Significant improvement was observed throughout the follow ups. The patient experienced marked relief in itching. The eruptions got better, scaling reduced. The patient was feeling better in the mental sphere as well. The Dermatology life Quality Index (DLQI) And Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 (DASS-21), statistical scales were used to assess the treatment's effectiveness, which also indicated considerable improvement following the treatment.
Conclusion-This case demonstrates that a carefully selected constitutional Homoeopathic remedy prescribed on the basis of the indicating totality of symptoms is effective and significant in cure of the patient of Tinea corporis.
KEYWORDS- Homoeopathy, Tinea Corporis, Skin eruptions, Cure, Totality of symptoms, Sepia Officinalis.
INTRODUCTION
Tinea corporis, also known as “ringworm” is a superficial dermatophyte infection of the skin. Tinea corporis typically presents as a well-demarcated, sharply circumscribed, oval or circular, mildly erythematous, scaly patch or plaque with a raised leading edge. Mild pruritus is common.[1]
Tinea corporis is mostly caused by dermatophytes belonging to one of the three genera, namely:-
· Trichophyton (which causes infections on skin, hair, and nails).
· Microsporum (which causes infections on skin and hair)
· Epidermophyton (which causes infections on skin and nails).[2]
Epidemiology And Demographics
Tinea corporis is exceedingly common worldwide. Dermatophytes are the most prevalent agents of superficial fungal infections. Excessive heat, high relative humidity, and fitted clothing have correlations to more severe and frequent disease.[2]
· Prevalence - Worldwide, the prevalence of dermatophytosis is 20000-25000 per 100,000 persons. The recent prevalence of dermatophytosis in India ranges from 36.6– 78.4%.
· Case-fatality rate - Dermatophytosis is a non- fatal, superficial infection of the skin.
· Gender - Overall, dermatophytosis is more common in women than in men. Groin infections occur with a higher frequency in males than in females. Nail infections occur more commonly in females than in males. [3]
International classification of diseases (ICD-11) for Tinea Corporis is SB72 Tinea circinate disorder (TM1).[4]
The standard treatment of tinea corporis is with topical antifungals. Systemic antifungal treatment is indicated if the lesion is multiple, extensive, deep, recurrent, chronic, or unresponsive to topical antifungal treatment, or if the patient is immunodeficient.[1]
Anti-fungal creams/ ointments/ treatments may potentially have adverse effects while homoeopathy could help the patient with rapid and gentle mode of improvement through the law of similars.
In the Organon of Medicine, in Aphorism 187, 190 and 225, Dr. Samuel Hahnemann explains that, the external ailments or the local affections has a cause, and it is a part of the internal malady, and to treat them with topical applications, as it was done in old-school, gives pernicious results. For judicious and radical cure of the general malady, internal remedies should be prescribed. He explained about Psycho-Somatic disorders that, they originate and are kept up by emotional causes, such as continued anxiety, worry, vexation, wrongs and the frequent occurrence of great fear and fright. This kind of emotional diseases in time destroys the corporeal health, often to a great degree. [5]
CASE PRESENTATION
Patient, Mr. M.A, 26 years, presented with Eruptions on Arms, axilla and chest since 1 month, to the OPD of Government homoeopathic medical college and hospital on 6th June, 2023. He was complaining of pruritic eruptions.Smarting and burning sensation after scratching. His complaints aggravated in cold air, while covering with clothes/ bedsheet and after physical exertion and sweating. Itching aggravates in the evening. Dryness and scaling on eruptions was present.
PAST HISTORY
History of Acne on face during adolescence. History of Jaundice at the age of 6 years.
FAMILY HISTORY
Father of the patient is Diabetic since 2 years, he is on allopathic medication. Mother of the patient has Chronic knee pain. She is also diagnosed with Hypothyroidism. The paient has 2 elder sisters who are Apparently healthy. Maternal uncle of the patient has Coronary artery disease.
TREATMENT HISTORY
Patient applied anti- fungal ointment and ring guard ointment before. But, complaints relapsed with more intensity.
PHYSICAL GENERALS
The patient’s Thermal Reaction is Towards Chilly. He Bathes regular with luke- warm water in winters. He takes 3 meals a day. He complaints of flatulence in evening. He Desires sweets and warm food. He is Intolerant to Spicy food as it causes heartburn. The tongue is clean and moist. He mostly perspires on the back, face, axilla which is non- offensive and non- staining. He complaints of offensive odour of urine. He is occasionally Constipated. He has refreshing sleep and mostly sleeps on lateral sides. He complaints of Anxious dreams once or twice in 10 days.
MENTAL GENERALS
Patient was born and brought up in Rewa, Madhya pradesh. He is experiencing difficulty in concentrating on work and other matters since the past few months. He has great anxiety about his health and health of his family members. Initially he was very enthusiastic about work, but now he feels very tired and does not want to work as before. He keeps on postponing his important work and studies. Hobbies- like to travel and likes to watch web series. He gets irritated on the slightest matters. He gets angry when someone lies on any matter. In anger, he directly confronts the person he is angry with. Academically, he is average. Confidence levels are average now, but, in childhood, he was under- confident and shy. He is Preparing for bank exams along with which he is working in a private company. He keeps his belongings in an organized manner. He is specific about Money matters and believes in Savings. He has fear of heights.
EXAMINATION
GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION-
He has a Mesomorphic build. He is Well nourished. Mild Pallor was present. No signs of jaundice, nails clubbing, cyanosis, oedema, lymphadenopathy. He has normal Gait.
VITALS
He was Afebrile (98.6 degree F) at the time of consultation. His Blood Pressure was 120/84 mm of Hg. Pulse rate was 76 beats per minute and Respiratory rate was18/ min
SENSES
His hearing is acute. His sight, smell and taste senses are normal.
SPECIFIC EXAMINATION- Of skin lesion
Erythematous eruption on Axilla, Upper part of chest. Edges/ periphery of the skin lesion was red with central clearing. Scaling was present. Dry patches of skin on periphery. Scratch marks of nails due to excessive pruritis. On the Left arm the Size of lesion was 14cm x 6 cm.
INVESTIGATION ADVISED
· Serum Hemoglobin
· Blood sugar- Fasting and Post prandial
DIAGNOSIS- TINEA CORPORIS
MIASMATIC DIAGNOSIS - Psoro- Sycosis is the pre-dominant miasm in this case.
REPERTORIAL ANALYSIS
Repertorization with RADAR 10.0 – Synthesis Repertory version 8.1V
(1) Mind, anxiety, health; about
(2) Mind, business, aversion to
(3) Mind, concentration, difficult
(4) Face, eruptions, chin
(5) Abdomen, flatulence, evening
(6) Chest, eruptions, axillae
(7) Chest, eruptions, axillae, herpes
(8) Extremities, eruptions, upper limbs
(9) Dreams; anxious
(10) Skin, eruptions, herpetic, circinate
(11) Skin, itching, scratching, agg.
(12) Generals, food and drinks, sweets, desire
REPERTORIAL RESULT
Sepia- 28/12
Sulph.- 23/11
Lyc.- 23/10
Nat.m.- 21/10
Rhus.t.- 21/10
Calc.- 18/10
Graph.- 17/10
Puls.- 19/9
FINAL SELECTION OF MEDICINE-
On the basis of proper case taking and repertorisation of the case, Sepia officinalis was the medicine which was selected in the 200 potency (on the basis of the susceptibility of the patient). Sepia officinalis covered the totality of symptoms with repertorial result of 28/12.
PRESCRIPTION
Rx-
Sepia Officinalis 200/ 4 Globules/ OD X 2 days. (in evening)
Sac. Lac. 30/ BD x 10 days
PRECAUTIONS/ ADVISE:
Patient was advised to keep the affected area clean, dry and to avoid scratching the area. He was advised to wear clean, dry clothes which are exposed to sunlight for some time. He was advised not to apply any allopathic anti-fungal creams rather to apply cold- pressed, coconut oil on the area of skin lesion.
Improvement assessment:
= Score before treatment – Score after treatment x 100
Score before treatment
= 10 – 3 x100 = 70.00%
10
COMMENT
Marked improvement of 70%.
There is marked reduction of DLQI score from 10 to 3.
OBSERVATION AND DISCUSSION
In this case of Tinea corporis, the patient presented with Pruritic eruptions with erythematous borders and central clearing. After carefully examining the case, totality of symptoms was formed. After repertorization and differentiation from Materia medica, Sepia Officinalis was the chosen remedy, which was prescribed on June 6, 2023, and the patient was asked to report to OPD after 15 days.
The patient showed some improvement during the initial follow up, but, itching was present. Then, on 26th June, 2023, he was prescribed 2 doses of Sepia Officinalis 200/ OD. Significant improvement was observed throughout the subsequent follow ups. The patient experienced marked relief in itching. The eruptions got better, scaling reduced. The patient was feeling better in the mental sphere as well.
Apart from Sepia Officinalis, Sulphur, Lycopodium, Natrum Mur, Rhus tox., Calcarea, Graphites and Pulsatilla received the highest values during repertorization.
After going through the Materia Medica, and considering the totality of symptoms, Sepia Officinalis was more similar to this case. Hence it was prescribed.
Homoeopathic medicine which was given, not only cured the current Physical complaints i.e, skin eruptions, but also, made the patient feel much better mentally. There was no relapse in his skin condition.
There is marked reduction of DLQI score from 10 to 3.
There is marked reduction of DASS-21 score from 25 to 11.
Indications of Sepia Officinalis in Tinea Corporis in Homoepathic Literatures also confirms to the patient’s symptoms:-
According to Dr. H.C. Allen : Sepia is "Adapted to persons of dark hair, rigid fibre but mild and easy disposition". Herpes circinatus in isolated spots on upper part of body (in intersecting rings over whole body, Tell.). [6]
According to Dr.William Boericke, Sepia Officinalis Acts specially on the portal system, with venous congestion. Herpes circinatus in isolated spots. Itching; not relieved by scratching; worse in bends of elbows and knees. Ringworm-like eruption every spring.[7]
The Patient was prescribed dose of Sepia Officinalis in the evening, rather than morning, as:- Dr. R.A.F. Jack stated “Sepia is to be given in the evening because if given in the morning, it may produce a sufficient aggravation to have the patient feeling quite useless for that day”.[8]
Previous Researches have shown the Anti-Fungal activity of Sepia
“ANTIFUNGAL ACTIVITY OF HOMOEOPATHIC MEDICINES SEPIA AND THEIR POTENCIES AGAINST CANDIDA ALBICANS”
Sepia 200 showed a maximum zone of inhibition as compared to sepia 30 CH. The effectiveness of zone inhibition against the growth of human pathogenic fungi Candida albicans were Antibiotics>Sepia 200CH>Sepia 30CH. The study suggested the inhibitory role of homoeopathic medicines against human pathogenic fungi Candida albicans. [9]
ANALYSIS OF ANTIFUNGAL ACTIVITY USING POWDERED CUTTLEBONE Sepia pharaonic; EHRENBERG, 1831 AGAINST SELECTED PATHOGENS
The results revealed that the methanolic extract of powdered cuttle bone possess relatively good antifungal activity which showed the presence of active principle present in it. [10]
CONCLUSION
The medicine selected on strictly homoeopathic principles and individualization, gives relief to the patient, helping in reducing the intensity of symptoms of Tinea corporis and also improving the patient's quality of life. The case study highlights the value of constitutional homoeopathic medicine prescribed on an individuality basis. It supports the fact that, in the treatment of Tinea Corporis, a simple minimum dose is necessary, followed by infrequent repetitions. However, this is a single case report, additional research must be done that may make this study useful.
CONSENT OF PATIENT
Patient has agreed that his images and other clinical information can be used for research work, and it can be reported in the journal.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I acknowledge the consent given by the patient to use his case and pictures for research and publication. I would like to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation to the management and staff of Government Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal, for their invaluable support. I would like to express my deepest appreciation to all the individuals who were directly or indirectly involved in this case.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST: There are no conflicts of interest.
FINANCIAL SUPPORT: Not Available
REFERENCES:
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7375854/
[2] Taplin D. Dermatophytosis in Vietnam. Cutis. 2001 May;67(5 Suppl):19-20. [PubMed]
[3] Expert consensus on the management of dermatophytosis in India (Ectoderm India) https://bmcdermatol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/ s12895-018- 0073-1#article-info
[4] https://www.findacode.com/icd-11/code-1620443808.html?hl=tinea
[5] Hahnemann S., Organon of Medicine. B. Jain Publishers (P) LTD.: 2015.
[6] Allen H.C. Allen's Keynotes Rearranged and Classified with Leading Remedies of the Materia Medica and Bowel Nosodes including REPERTORIAL INDEX; edition 2005, B.Jain publishers (P) LTD. p. 278-281.
[7] Boericke W.; Pocket manual of homoeopathic materia medica and repertory and a chapter on rare and uncommon remedies; B. Jain Publishers (P) LTD. p.518- 520.
[8] https://www.homeobook.com/sorry-for-person-who- are-loved-best-sepia/
[9] Indian Journal of Psychology Book No.05 2023 ISSN: 0019-5553; p.15
[10] UTTAR PRADESH JOURNAL OF ZOOLOGY; 43(24): 429-434, 2022 ISSN: 0256-971X (P); p.429
